Are sparks of revolution meaningless if they don't immediately catch fire?
After the book released last year, the next instalment in the Hunger Games movie franchise is finally here. For many people this is one of the most anticipated films of the year, but does it live up to the expectations? And how does it match up to the book and previous films?
Set 24 years before the first Hunger Games film, Sunrise on the Reaping takes place during the Second Quarter Quell and centres around Haymitch Abernathy. It's a story fans of the original trilogy are familiar with: Haymitch facing off against double the amount of tributes and winning the 50th Hunger Games, but the Capitol's propaganda is ever present, and the real story may be a bit more complex than you were made to believe.
Much like the Second Quarter Quell Sunrise on the Reaping is a spectacle. The scale has clearly increased from the previous film, as the arena is huge, spanning a massive field, woods, and looming mountains, with a cornucopia surrounded by flowers in the middle. While it is all quite mesmerising to look at, beneath this glamour is an emotional character study, as we watch Haymitch slowly become the man he is in the original trilogy. The film really comes alive during its quieter moments.
If you're familiar with the book, you know how heart-wrenching it is, and the film definitely lives up to that. While the omission of Haymitch's internal monologue makes a few scenes a little less impactful, they are nevertheless incredibly emotional and will surely tug on your heartstrings – I for one was in tears at the end.
The casting announcements for this film made waves last year, which is why it is no surprise that most performances are stellar. But two standouts among the supporting cast are Glenn Close and Kieran Culkin. Glenn Close plays Drusilla Sickle, Effie Trinket's predecessor as District 12's escort, and in the book is a minor character. She has her moments, but her presence is largely confined to one or two scenes. A character such as this could easily be forgotten or reduced in adaptation, yet Glenn Close makes Drusilla not only memorable but a menacing personification of the Capitol. Close elevates this character and even makes me wish we got more scenes with her.
Kieran Culkin, on the other hand, plays a younger version of Caesar Flickerman. He's not yet the polished TV host he becomes later, rather a mean-spirited interviewer who clearly sees the tributes as nothing more than props on his talk show. He has always been the Capitol's mouthpiece, but this version of him makes it the most clear: there is no sympathy, no matter how false, in Culkin's Caesar Flickerman. He commands every scene he is in, no matter how short, with quipping lines that are reportedly completely improvised.
In comparison to a few other cast members who are clearly inspired by previous interpretations of their characters, Culkin doesn't really take inspiration from Stanley Tucci's Flickerman. The similarities are confined to a select few mannerisms, which in this case works in his favour and elevates the character. I'm sure many people, particularly book fans, will be asking for an extended version of the film that includes his full tribute interviews.
Of course you can't forget Joseph Zada as Haymitch, a star-making performance. Zada truly becomes Haymitch, echoing Woody Harrelson's portrayal, especially nailing the accent. Every time he said "sweetheart", it was as if Harrelson was suddenly back on screen.
Sadly, one disappointment is the amount of censorship. In comparison to previous films, Sunrise on the Reaping is by far the most toned down regarding violence, ironic considering the subject matter. It's occasionally a little jarring how safe they play it, having a character dragged across concrete for several metres but emerging with only minor injuries, yet supposedly dying from their wounds. It's understandable that they wanted to keep the PG-13 rating, but it's sadly at the expense of the narrative, momentarily taking you out of the film.
Another issue is that certain moments concerning the worldbuilding feel very heavy-handed and spoon-fed. It's like Suzanne Collins saw people fail to grasp her last book and decided to abandon subtext altogether, and the film only exacerbates this problem. It turns an already unsubtle book into an even less subtle film. However, a few of the movie's original scenes do add a bit more to the story and even new information about Panem. Especially a certain mysterious and morally dubious character gets a lot of extra screen time.
While there are a few gripes I and others will surely have with Sunrise on the Reaping, it is still an incredibly entertaining film and a great addition to the Hunger Games franchise. I am very curious to see where this movie will rank in the fans' eyes. Will Sunrise on the Reaping be another divisive Songbirds and Snakes, or will the spectacle of a Quarter Quell prevail, putting it up there with Catching Fire? In my opinion, while this film does have the ingredients for greatness, it doesn't quite manage to grasp it. It sadly never fully catches fire, which is, in a way, quite poetic.
Oh, and one last thing: Suzanne Collins, please give us a Plutarch book.
Support our work
You can subscribe to the OBSCURAE newsletter for free, or become a paid Aficionado for £5/month to help fund independent coverage, contributor fees, site hosting, and admin costs.