This contains spoilers for Rivals up to and including Episode 9. Proceed as you would at a Venturer board meeting: carefully and, as it turns out, trusting no one.
I finished Rivals Season 2, Part 1 convinced that Maud hadn't just been cheating on her hot husband, Declan O’Hara, with his sworn enemy, Tony Baddingham, but that she had been giving away secrets. Pillow talk but make it corporate espionage. Reader, I was wrong.
With Maud crossed off the suspects list, and Cameron never that high on it – if only because I do think the writers are aware of the optics of the only Black woman on the show being a traitor, plus Tony has already accused her of it once – it's time to round up the suspects.
One of the many things this show has been very good at is emotional punches. Raise your hand and a tissue if the screen suddenly got blurry when Archie delivered his eulogy for his mother, and no one was coming to comfort him until Caitlin stepped in. So, the mole needs to hurt. Properly hurt. Falling off a polo pony at full speed hurt.
- Rule #1: I am ruling out the three co-founders, Declan O’Hara, Rupert Campbell-Black and Freddie Jones, because they all have too much skin in the game, and for them it’s personal against Tony.
- Rule #2: The mole is unlikely to be a woman, because in Episode 9, Tony’s henchman Ginger says the mole is "still making himself useful”. Usually, when screenwriters make a point of using gendered pronouns, my suspicion antenna starts twitching. But here, I feel this is more of a wink to the audience, after we thought that the mole was Maud.
- Rule #3: No secondary Venturer members. Bishop Hubert Brenton, Wesley Emerson the cricketer, and Toshi Yamazaki the robotics genius are out because we haven’t built enough rapport with them. Episode 7 ended with Freddie and Declan wondering who the mole might be, Episode 8 gave the plotline a lot of screen time, and Episode 9 revisits the mystery, so you know it’s going to have a big payoff. You don’t build that up for a reveal that makes the audience go “who?”
Dame Enid
I said no woman, but Tony and Ginger are the kind of men who would think it’s very funny to act as if a butch woman is a man. And Dame Enid wears fantastic, very masc three-piece suits. She has, however, made clear how much she hates Tony, both because of his boorish approach to culture, and because he made Monica miserable. A woman who despises him that thoroughly isn’t passing him notes, only judgment.
Likelihood: 1/10, about the odds of Rupert keeping his shirt on for a whole episode
Mike Maples
Sure, Mike had access to the tapes of the Golden Gauntlet that Tony hijacked. And he has a soft spot for Daysee. And Declan spent much of Episode 8 giving him the suspicious side-eye. The tech guy doing it is more Midsomer Murders than Rivals, though.
Likelihood: 2/10, about the odds of Tony ever admitting he was wrong.
Lord Hampshire
What if beneath the blundering tweed lies a criminal mastermind? Henry has been more present recently, but mostly through his daughter’s marriage plot. This is a series that’s been very good on class, so there could be a commentary there about the British landed gentry sticking together, but I think it would be too minor to register as a twist.
Likelihood: 3/10, about the odds of a Rutshire dinner party ending without someone sleeping with someone else’s spouse.
Charles Fairburn
Charles the double, triple, possibly quadruple agent? At this stage, it is a bit hard to believe that Tony wouldn’t have heard of his duplicity. The man is at all Venturer functions, and the Venturer people turn up for him – most visibly at his mother’s funeral. Charles-the-mole would hurt the viewer, who would feel cheated, more than it would hurt the characters. Taggie would be heartbroken, but Taggie will be heartbroken no matter who it is; it’s her default setting.
Likelihood: 4/10, about the odds of James Vereker noticing his wife’s feelings.

Bas(il) Baddingham
Brother of, and therefore a bit too obvious. Bas has had a lot of character development across Episodes 7-9. He seems a lot more embedded in the Baddingham family life than we’ve seen so far. I was surprised when he suggested hosting his teenage nieces for the night when their father had a breakdown, which shows that they already have a good relationship. Uncle Bas – who knew?
His relationship with Taggie has been a nice build-up, although the screenwriters were quick to remind us what a cad he is when he bets £100 he will get in her knickers in less than three months and then has a threesome with movie star Nathalie Perrault and one of the interchangeable polo-playing twins. He clearly loves his brother, although Tony bullies him too, so he could be the mole to get his approval. Bas is an obvious choice, and therefore he would be disappointing. Rivals rarely is.
Likelihood: 6/10, about the odds of Bas losing that £100 bet.
Gerald Middleton, MP
My frontrunner. Remember how I said it was weird that no one at Corinium knew – or cared – about Charles’ double-agenting? Gerald-the-mole could explain it. Gerald isn’t in every Venturer meeting, but Charles is, and Charles would trust Gerald with all the secrets.
As for motives: we’re in 1987. Sexual acts between men over 21 had been decriminalised for 20 years, but we’re just a few months away from Section 28 being enacted. Three-quarters of the British population believed that homosexuality was “always or mostly wrong”, an attitude worsened by the misunderstanding around AIDS – Episode 7 shows that well with the broadcast of an awful ad and the Hampshires being cruelly homophobic in front of Gerald.
For Gerald, a Tory MP, being outed would be a death knell. As we saw in Episode 8, he is ready to get married to hide his sexuality and stay on track for the red boxes. That makes him easy to blackmail, and Tony would have no qualms doing so if he got hold of compromising photos or similar. After all, Tony did try something similar with Declan.
It would also be the cruellest choice: it would devastate Charles, who can’t quit him however awful he gets, and sting Rupert, who gave Gerald his start. Et tu, Gerald? Long term, however, it could be the push Charles needs to move on. Maybe we could even get a happy gay love story for once.
Likelihood: 8/10, about the odds of Tony having a whisky in his hand when the truth comes out.
My money’s on Gerald. If I’m wrong, Rupert can keep his shirt on for an entire episode. Who’s your mole? Tell me in the comments.
Support our work
You can subscribe to the OBSCURAE newsletter for free, or become a paid Aficionado for £5/month to help fund independent coverage, contributor fees, site hosting, and admin costs.